Tuesday, September 06, 2005

Our Book of the Month: The New American Militarism

Tonight at Books and Books we are going to be discussing Andrew Bacevich's The New American Militarism: How Americans are Seduced by War. Mr. Bacevich, as all the reviews attest, is a graduate of West Point, Viet Vet and eventually ended up at the Center for International Relations at Boston University. You can find a moderate left critique of the book here and a loony left one here. A review from the moderate right can be read here. The one completely fawning review is by paleo-conservative Paul Craig Roberts. This makes sense since as even the review from the mod right noted Bacevich's ideas seem rooted in the old right. A great deal of what Bacevich writes reminds me of Robert Nisbet and his remarkable bookform essay The Present Age. Writing in 1988 the rabid anti-Communist Nisbet bemoaned the fact that starting with WWI the US had essentially been at war for 75 years. He deplored militarism and shared Bacevich's aversion to Woodrow Wilson and his ideas. Further evidence of the paleo-con love for Bacevich can be found at LewRockwell.com.

You can find an interviews with Bacevich
here and here. You can read an article wrote about "the living room war" for The American Conservative here and a piece on Tommy Franks for the New Left Review here.

2 Comments:

Blogger IJ said...

Trackback from Coming Anarchy.

“Wanting to fight is an ordinary emotion for those who choose combat arms as a profession.”

The Cardinal’s website has a review of ‘The New American Militarism: How Americans Are Seduced By War’. The author, Andrew J. Bacevich, is a “Vietnam veteran, professional soldier and West Point graduate”.

A link there to an interview with Bacevich contains the exchange:

Questioner: You summarize the relationship between the public and the military with the phrase, “We admire you. Now go away.” This seems to describe a militarism that is rather hollow such that “supporting the troops” is some part of national piety, but nothing else. How would you further describe the relationship between the public and the armed services?
AB:It’s a phony respect. We proclaim our support for the troops as long as doing so comes without cost.

The attitude that comes across is more Barnett than Kaplan.

2:50 PM  
Blogger theCardinal said...

Thanks for the mention in Coming Anarchy...I was honored to be even mentioned on my favorite blog.

1:23 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home